I recommend stock too . . . in fact, I will take it step further. I'd drop back from a 1600 dual port (stock for a '73) to a 1600 single port. You will loose a little top end speed, but a single port is much more durable and has better low end torque.
I push a 73 bay window bus (at least 1 and half times heavier than your Super Beetle) around with a bone stock 1600 single port engine. It's a little sluggish on take off and slows a little on hills, but I go where ever I want to and, except for one time, always get back. Back in June I drove it to FunFest in Effingham, IL. In previous years I've driven it to Florida Bug Blast near Tampa. Between trips like that, I drive it work every day.
I've never tried it, but I've been told by someone who should know, that adding a set of ratio rocker to a stock single port engine will really "wake it up." That might be a good option if you want a little more pep, but want to keep it dependable. Talk it over with Ret.Bugtech . . . he knows his stuff!
