I don't have an automatic transmission, but I shift it into neutral to coast every now and then too. I also don't have a real-time MPG calculator, but I'm sure it would show a similar readout.
Here is something to consider though. If you're coasting in neutral, the engine has to consume a little bit of fuel to keep the engine running at idle speed. In most modern cars with a manual transmission, you can actually use zero fuel if you are coasting in gear. The car's momentum will keep the engine turning and as long as your foot is off the accelerator the engine will cut off the fuel delivery.